Book Review: Monitoring Your Baby in Labour – What Does the Evidence Actually Say?

(Review of Chapter 1 from the book by Dr Kirsten Small)

When you are in labour, healthcare professionals usually monitor your baby’s heartbeat. The reason is simple: they want to check if your baby is coping well with labour.

Most people assume that more monitoring means more safety.

But according to obstetrician and researcher Dr Kirsten Small, the story may not be that simple.

Her book explores the research behind fetal heart rate monitoring so pregnant people can make informed decisions about what they want during labour.

Let’s break down the key ideas from Chapter 1.

Why Babies Are Monitored in Labour

During labour, care providers often check the baby’s heartbeat because changes in heart rate can sometimes show if a baby is stressed or not getting enough oxygen.

There are two main ways this is done:

1. Intermittent auscultationListening to the baby’s heartbeat at regular intervals using a handheld device.

2. Continuous CTG monitoringA machine called a Cardiotocograph (CTG) records the baby’s heart rate continuously using sensors on the mother’s abdomen.

For decades, many professionals believed that continuous monitoring could prevent brain injury or death in babies.

But when Dr Small looked closely at the research, she found something surprising.

A Big Claim: CTG Monitoring May Not Work the Way We Think

After reviewing decades of studies, Dr Small argues that many claims about CTG monitoring are not supported by strong evidence.

She says CTG monitoring was introduced into maternity care before good research proved that it actually improved outcomes for babies.

Today, it is still widely used — even though the evidence behind it is more complex than most people realise.

Her message is not that monitoring is always bad.

Instead, she argues that parents deserve honest information about what research actually shows.

The Problem With “Risk Categories”

In maternity care, pregnant people are often placed into two groups:

• Low risk

• High risk

This is based on lists of medical factors such as health conditions, pregnancy complications, or events during labour.

If someone is labelled high risk, they are usually advised to have continuous CTG monitoring.

If they are labelled low risk, intermittent listening is often recommended.

But Dr Small believes these categories can be too simple for something as complex as birth.

She argues that every pregnancy is unique and decisions should be individualised rather than based on labels alone.

Do Women Always Get a Choice?

Research shows something concerning.

Many women are not told they have a choice about fetal monitoring.

Instead, the type of monitoring is often decided by the care provider.

Dr Small believes this needs to change.

She says pregnant people should:

• Understand the options• Know the research• Be involved in decisions about their care

Because your birth experience matters too — not just the medical outcome.

What This Book Aims to Do

The goal of the book is simple.

It helps readers understand:

• The different types of fetal monitoring• What the research says about them• The pros and cons of each option• How to make your own decision

It also gives practical tips on how to talk with healthcare professionals about your choices.

Why This Conversation Matters

Birth is not just a medical event.

It is a life-changing experience.

Safety includes more than survival. It also includes emotional wellbeing, respectful care, and feeling informed about what is happening to your body and your baby.

Dr Small believes maternity care should support both physical safety and personal autonomy.

And that begins with access to clear, honest information.

Get Your Free Guide

To further explore the concepts presented in this chapter, download our FREE GUIDE